Consumers need protection from unrealistic claims of home genetic tests, new report states (8/19/2010)
 | | This is James P. Evans, M.D., Ph.D., from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill School of Medicine. - UNC Medical Center News Office |
Direct to consumer (DTC) genetic tests are increasingly being marketed to the public via television, print ads, and the Internet. These home genetic tests provide access to a person's genomic information without necessarily involving a doctor or insurance company in the process.
Writing in the August 18, 2010 Online First edition of the New England Journal of Medicine, medical geneticist James P. Evans, MD, PhD from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill School of Medicine and the UNC Lineberger Comprehensive Cancer Center, and co-authors David C. Dale, MD from the University of Washington, and Cathy Fomous, PhD from the National Institutes of Health, state that medical professionals "must ensure that rapidly evolving and multiplying genomic technologies are responsibly harnessed and that their promise is not oversold to the public."
In their article, "Preparing for a Consumer-Driven Genomic Age," the authors argue that "a primary role of health care professionals in the future may be to interpret their patients' DTC genetic test results and advise them about appropriate follow-up."
While the authors acknowledge that individuals should continue to be permitted direct access to their genomic information, they note that "consumers must be protected from unrealistic claims and the misinterpretation of complex and dynamic genomic information."
Noting that segments of the public already embrace DTC genetic tests, the authors point out that in many cases, there is "little or no evidence of the clinical validity of tests developed from genetic technologies." The authors state that clinical validity data "are limited because they can be difficult and expensive to obtain and because there is no FDA requirement for the premarketing submission of such data for most genetic tests."
In testimony last month to the House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, Evans stressed that consumers "?deserve an honest accounting of what such information means and the assurance that it is derived in a manner that ensures quality, reliability and confidentiality."
Note: This story has been adapted from a news release issued by the University of North Carolina School of Medicine
Post Comments:
| 
Subscribe
Tiny water creepy crawlies from South Korea and the Russian Far East
NASA satellite data helps pinpoint glaciers' role in sea level rise
Weather on the outer planets only goes so deep
Shattering the endurance record for small electric UAV
But what does it do?
Artificial forest for solar water-splitting
Sea level influenced tropical climate during the last ice age
World's smallest droplets
Using clay to grow bone
Grammar errors? The brain detects them even when you are unaware
Principles of locomotion in confined spaces could help robot teams work underground
Researchers perform fastest measurements ever made of ion channel proteins
Ultraresponsive magnetic nanoscavengers for next generation water purification
Do potatoes grow on vines? A review of the wild relatives of some favorite food plants
New discovery of ancient diet shatters conventional ideas of how agriculture emerged
Untangling the tree of life
More effective, cheaper concrete manufactured with ash from olive residue biomass
Seahorse's armor gives engineers insight into robotics designs
New quantitative analysis for open source software projects
High-volume Bitcoin exchanges less likely to fail, but more likely breached, says study
Computer scientists develop video game that teaches how to program in Java
Do palm trees hold the key to immortality?
Researchers show how we can do math problems unconsciously
Keep moving and have fun
New strategy for fingerprint visualization developed at Hebrew University
Children's bicycle helmets shown to be effective in impact and crush tests
How Usain Bolt can run faster -- effortlessly
Enhancing cognition in older adults also changes personality
DNA-guided assembly yields novel ribbon-like nanostructures
Carnivorous plant throws out 'junk' DNA
What is the role of double-stranded RNA in antiviral host defense systems?
Mining the botulinum genome
Sacred lotus genome sequence enlightens scientists